29 August 2023

Goals Toolkit: How to Set & Achieve Your Goals - Dr Andrew Huberman

The Unified Neural Circuit for Goal Pursuit:

  • Regardless of the goal (from planning a craft day to building a billion-dollar company), the brain uses one common neural circuit for all goal setting, pursuit, and assessment.
  • This circuit involves four key brain areas:
    • The amygdala, associated with fear and anxiety, which motivates us to avoid punishments or failures.
    • The basal ganglia (specifically the ventral striatum), which includes "go" circuits for initiating action and "no-go" circuits for preventing action.
    • The lateral prefrontal cortex, responsible for executive functions like planning and thinking across different timescales (immediate vs. long-term goals).
    • The orbitofrontal cortex, which meshes emotionality with current progress and compares it to future emotional states when a goal is reached.
  • These circuits boil down to two functions: assessing value (is something worth pursuing?) and action (which actions to take or not take).

Dopamine: The Molecule of Motivation:

  • Dopamine is the primary neuromodulator governing goal setting, assessment, and pursuit; it's the "common currency" for assessing the value of our pursuits.
  • Unlike common belief, dopamine is primarily the molecule of motivation, not just pleasure. Animals and humans depleted of dopamine lose the motivation to seek pleasure, even if they can still experience it.
  • Reward Prediction Error: Dopamine release is highest for unexpected positive events. Anticipated rewards lead to dopamine release during anticipation, but less when the reward actually occurs, especially if it's expected. If an anticipated reward doesn't happen, dopamine drops below baseline, causing disappointment.

Neuroplasticity and the 85% Rule for Optimal Learning:

  • The brain's ability to change in response to experience (neuroplasticity) underlies all learning.
  • Errors are crucial for neuroplasticity: Feeling frustrated after an error makes brain areas more alert, increasing focus and the probability of learning on subsequent attempts.
  • Optimal learning occurs with an 85% success rate: When learning something new, the task's difficulty should be set so that you get things right about 85% of the time and make errors about 15% of the time. This means goals should be pretty hard but not so hard that you fail constantly. This rule applies to both self-learning and teaching.

Peripersonal vs. Extrapersonal Space for Goal Orientation:

  • Peripersonal space includes your body and immediate surroundings. Thoughts and consummatory behaviors (enjoying what you have) in this space are governed by neurochemicals like serotonin.
  • Extrapersonal space is everything beyond your immediate reach (the next room, a distant goal). Orienting towards this space is primarily driven by dopamine.
  • Effective goal pursuit requires the ability to toggle between understanding your present state (peripersonal) and orienting towards future goals (extrapersonal).

Harnessing Visual Focus for Goal Execution (Exteroception):

  • Narrow visual attention significantly enhances goal pursuit effectiveness. Studies show that visually focusing on a goal line can lead to achieving goals with 17% less perceived effort and 23% quicker.
  • This is because focusing vision on a single point (engaging the parvocellular visual pathway) increases systolic blood pressure and releases adrenaline, readying the body for action and moving it into "goal pursuit mode".
  • Actionable Practice: To initiate focused work or physical activity, focus your visual attention on one point beyond your immediate reach (e.g., a spot on a wall, your computer screen, the horizon) for 30-60 seconds. This practice can increase cognitive attention and readiness for goal pursuit.
  • Multitasking: While generally advised against, multitasking before focused work can increase adrenaline, putting you into an "action" state. However, do not multitask during focused goal pursuit.

Visualization Strategies for Goal Maintenance:

  • Visualize your future self: Seeing digitally aged images of oneself can bridge "delay discounting" (goals feel less rewarding the further out they are) and significantly increase motivation for long-term goals like saving for retirement or investing in health.
  • Foreshadow Failure, Don't Just Visualize Success: While visualizing the "big win" can kickstart goal pursuit, it's a poor way to maintain action. Routinely focusing on how things could fail and the negative consequences of not taking action almost doubles the likelihood of reaching a goal. This leverages the amygdala's role in anxiety and the brain's strong bias for learning from negative experiences.

Setting Goals with Appropriate Difficulty:

  • Goals should be challenging but possible (moderate difficulty). Goals that are too easy don't sufficiently engage the autonomic nervous system or increase systolic blood pressure, leading to quick abandonment. Goals that are too lofty can overwhelm and demotivate.
  • Moderate, genuinely challenging goals are most effective in recruiting the physiological readiness needed for sustained effort.

Limiting Options and Specificity of Action:

  • Limit the number of major goals you pursue simultaneously (1-3 major goals per year is often sufficient). Too many goals, or too many visual distractions, can diffuse attention and hinder progress.
  • Concrete plans are essential: Vague goals like "be more fit" are less effective than specific action steps (e.g., "run five miles four times a week before 8 AM"). Define "what right looks like" in terms of actions, not just feeling states.

Assessing Progress and Self-Reward:

  • Assess progress consistently: Weekly assessment is a good rule of thumb for reviewing performance and updating action plans.
  • Subjective self-reward is critical: Our subjective understanding of why we're doing something profoundly affects the outcomes. Cognitively reward yourself by acknowledging progress (e.g., "I'm on track") on a consistent schedule. This re-ups dopamine, fostering motivation and readiness to continue.
  • Avoid over-reliance on external dopamine-increasing substances, as behavioral tools engage neuroplasticity for long-term gains in focus and motivation.

Space-Time Bridging Protocol:

  • This is a practice to consciously shift your visual and cognitive attention between interoception (internal state) and exteroception (external world) across different distances. This trains your brain to flexibly manage different timescales of goals.
  • Steps (can be done sitting or standing, ideally outdoors or with a horizon view):
    1. Close your eyes: Focus all attention on your internal landscape (breathing, heart rate, skin sensations) for approximately three slow breaths.
    2. Open eyes, focus on your body: Focus visual attention on an area of your body (e.g., palm of your hand) for three breaths, splitting attention (approx. 90% internal, 10% external).
    3. Focus on near external object: Move visual attention to an object 5-15 feet away for three breaths (biasing towards exteroception, ~90% external, 10% internal for breathing cadence).
    4. Focus on far external object/horizon: Shift visual attention to the furthest point you can see (horizon) for three breaths (99-100% external focus).
    5. Broad visual field: Expand your visual focus to take in as much of the entire landscape as possible (magnocellular vision) for three breaths.
    6. Return to internal landscape: Close eyes and return to 100% interoception for three breaths.
  • Repeat these stations 2-3 times. The entire practice takes 90 seconds to 3 minutes.
  • This practice teaches your visual and cognitive systems to "batch time" differently, allowing better alignment with short-term milestones and long-term goals.

In summary, effective goal achievement is rooted in understanding the brain's motivational circuitry (dopamine and the amygdala), embracing challenges (the 85% rule), leveraging visual attention, anticipating potential failures to drive action, setting moderately difficult and concrete goals, and consistently rewarding subjective progress.