28 May 2023

The Basics of Preventing Cardiovascular Disease, Cancer and Dementia - Modern Wisdom with Dr Peter Attia

Dr Peter Attia has his own podcast that goes into a lot of detail on the subjects of preventing cardiovascular disease, cancer and dementia through exercise, diet and sleep. Here is a podcast where he discusses them on another presenter's podcast and thus you get a good high level summary

Learning Points:

  • Holistic View of Longevity: Attia emphasises focusing on both lifespan and healthspan, encompassing physical, emotional, and mental health, rather than just extending years.
  • Low-Tech Fundamentals Over Biohacking: While fascinated by high-tech advancements, Attia advocates for a somewhat low-tech approach, stressing that fundamental practices like maintaining a high VO2 max and being incredibly strong will do more for lifespan and healthspan than most biohacking or gut biome manipulation.
  • Risk Management in Life Decisions: Drawing from his background at McKinsey, Attia applies principles of risk management, probability, and statistics to daily life. He advises individuals to think about symmetric and asymmetric risk, expected value, and hedging risk in every decision, weighing the upside against the downside.
  • Compliance as the Longest Lever: The most critical factor for any health programme is adherence and compliance. Systems and protocols must be personalised to work for the individual; high-bar approaches that lead to failure are counterproductive.
  • Nutrition is Personal: There are three main strategies for reducing caloric intake (for those who are "overnourished"): calorie counting, dietary restriction (identifying "boogeymans"), or time restriction. The best approach is the one that works for you and that you can consistently maintain.
  • Distinguishing "Fast Death" from "Slow Death": Modern medicine (Medicine 2.0) has been incredibly successful at treating "fast death" (e.g., trauma, infectious diseases), effectively doubling human lifespan to about 80 years. However, little progress has been made against "slow death" – chronic diseases like cardiovascular disease, cancer, neurodegenerative disease, and metabolic disease – which are the focus of longevity efforts.
  • Objective-Strategy-Tactics Framework: For long-term health goals, it's crucial to establish a clear objective, then develop a strategy to achieve it, and finally implement tactics. Most people skip the strategy step and jump straight to tactics, leading to confusion.
  • The "Marginal Decade": This framework involves defining what you want to be true in the last decade of your life (e.g., walking a dog, picking up grandchildren, maintaining cognitive function). This objective then dictates the necessary actions today.
  • Building Reserves for Decline: To achieve marginal decade goals, one must build up enormous reserves in physical capacities today to anticipate the inevitable decline that comes with aging.
  • Strategic Insight Pillars: Since large-scale, long-term human randomised controlled trials are rare for longevity, strategy relies on five pillars: inferences from observational data (e.g., centenarians), short-term human studies, animal literature, mechanistic studies (cellular level understanding), and Mendelian randomisation (nature's controlled experiments).
  • Five Domains of Longevity Tactics: These are nutrition, exercise and movement, sleep, drugs/molecules/supplements/hormones, and emotional/mental health.
  • Majoring in the Minor (Nutrition): Many people overemphasise the "finer details" of nutrition (e.g., exact omega ratios) once the fundamentals of energy balance and adequate protein intake are met. The evidence doesn't strongly support the overwhelming importance of these minor details.
  • MTOR Activation: Acute activation of the mTOR pathway (important for anabolism) is necessary, especially through amino acid intake. Chronically elevated mTOR can be an issue for metabolically ill individuals, but undue restriction of amino acids to limit mTOR can lead to sarcopenia (muscle loss as we age).
  • Time-Restricted Feeding & Protein: While a viable strategy for caloric reduction, time-restricted feeding (intermittent fasting) does not appear to have any magical benefits beyond the caloric restriction it brings. It can also make it harder to consume adequate protein, potentially leading to muscle loss.
  • Protein Intake Sweet Spot: For optimal muscle building and maintenance, aiming for 25-50 grams of protein per serving, spread out over multiple meals, is recommended to avoid the liver converting amino acids to glucose.
  • Artificial Sweeteners and Sugar Appetite: While aspartame has extensive safety data at regular doses, artificial sweeteners may increase appetite for sugar, making it harder to reduce sweet things entirely. Allulose is noted as a preferred natural sweetener due to taste and potential glucose-lowering effects.
  • Overlooked Key Health Metrics: VO2 max is the metric most highly correlated with a person's lifespan, yet few people know theirs. Appendicular lean mass index (muscle mass) and strength are also highly predictive. Additionally, accurate blood pressure measurement is crucial, as undiagnosed hypertension is an epidemic and a major risk factor for Alzheimer's and cardiovascular disease.
  • Cardiorespiratory Fitness Pyramid: Improving VO2 max involves building a wide "base" (aerobic efficiency) through Zone 2 training and raising the "peak" through high-intensity intervals.
  • Strength Training Principles: Focus on generating force, typically in the 5-15 rep range, aiming for 0-2 reps in reserve (meaning stopping just before failure) to minimise injury risk and ensure long-term consistency. Prioritise large, compound lifts.
  • The Importance of Stability Training: Often overlooked, stability training is crucial for preventing "energy leaks" (injuries) in joints and improving overall movement efficiency, similar to how a track car's stiff chassis transmits power better than a street car's. It often involves rebuilding fundamental movement patterns from early childhood.
  • Nicotine vs. Delivery Vehicle: Nicotine itself is not the primary problem; the toxicity of the delivery vehicle (e.g., tobacco in cigarettes, heated filaments/combustible products in some vaping devices) is the concern.
  • Alcohol's Detrimental Impact on Sleep: Alcohol acts as a sedative but does not promote restorative sleep. It significantly impairs heart rate variability (HRV), increases heart rate, and elevates respiratory rate, pushing the body into a "fight-or-flight" state rather than "rest and digest".
  • Prophylactics Against Mental Degradation: Exercise, lipid management, avoiding type 2 diabetes, and adequate sleep are the "no-regret moves" with enormous, unambiguous impact on improving cognition and delaying dementia.
  • Exercise as the Longest Longevity Lever: Statistically, cardiorespiratory fitness (VO2 max) and strength have hazard ratios that dwarf other major risk factors like smoking, hypertension, and diabetes in terms of their impact on all-cause mortality.
  • Heart Disease Drivers: The primary drivers of atherosclerosis (which leads to heart attacks) are smoking, high blood pressure (above 120/80), and high APO B levels. Evolution didn't select against these because they didn't interfere with reproductive fitness in the past.
  • Targeted Pharmacology: Attia suggests that pharmacology can be a better tool than draconian dietary measures for specific problems (e.g., lowering lipids) if it can solve the issue without creating multiple other problems (e.g., hormone imbalances, muscle loss).
  • Purpose over Motivation for Consistency: Long-term adherence is driven by purpose, not fleeting motivation. Anchoring decisions to the "marginal decade" helps maintain consistency over the decades required for longevity.
  • Social Connection is Vital: Humans are "evolutionarily wired to be social creatures." Loneliness is an enormous predisposing factor for suicide and engaging in "parasuicide" behaviours (reckless acts that shorten life). Quality relationships are inextricably linked to the enjoyment and quality of life.
  • Emotional Health as a Top Priority: Emotional health should not be an afterthought; poor emotional health is "probably a curse", even with extended lifespan.
  • Rejuvenative Practices: Activities like sauna, cold plunging, rucking (without electronics), and "playing" (especially with family) are crucial for both physical and mental well-being.
  • The "Right Now" Advantage: While younger individuals have the greatest compounding benefit from early changes, the "marginal decade" is an abstract concept. Older individuals have more motivation but less room to alter their course. Therefore, the perfect time to start is always today.

Action Points:

  1. Prioritise Foundational Fitness: "Put in the work" to achieve a very high VO2 max and be incredibly strong, as these are more impactful than any technology or biohacking.
  2. Adopt a Risk Management Mindset: Evaluate decisions by weighing the upside and downside. For instance, consider if the pleasure derived from an activity (e.g., skiing) justifies the potential risks (e.g., injury), understanding that individual risk-reward profiles vary.
  3. Personalise Your Health Program: Experiment with different approaches (e.g., calorie counting, dietary restriction, time-restricted eating) to find a system for nutrition and exercise that you can consistently adhere to, rather than setting an impossibly high bar.
  4. Define Your "Marginal Decade" Objectives: Clearly articulate what you want your life to look like in your last decade. Envision specific activities like walking a dog, picking up grandchildren, or engaging in complex conversations, and use these as anchors for your current health decisions.
  5. Build Capacity Today for Future Needs: "Reverse engineer" your goals from your marginal decade. For example, to walk a golden retriever at 90, you must build significant reserves of strength, balance, and lower-leg variability now to anticipate future decline.
  6. Focus on the Five Domains of Longevity: Address all aspects of your health: how you eat, how you exercise and move, how you sleep, any drugs/molecules/supplements/hormones you take, and your emotional and mental health.
  7. Optimise Protein Intake: Aim for 25-50 grams of protein per serving, distributed over several meals throughout the day, to maximise muscle synthesis and avoid amino acids being used as glucose. If using time-restricted feeding, ensure protein goals are met, potentially with a low-calorie protein shake outside the eating window.
  8. Be Mindful of Sweeteners: While artificial sweeteners may not be acutely toxic, consider reducing sweet things altogether to reset your palate and reduce cravings for sugar. If using sweeteners, allulose is a preferred option.
  9. Measure and Track Key Metrics: Get a VO2 max test. Understand your appendicular lean mass index (muscle mass) and strength relative to your age and sex. Regularly and accurately measure your blood pressure at home, following a strict protocol, and aim for readings at or below 120/80.
  10. Implement a Balanced Cardio Training Protocol:
    • Zone 2 Training: Engage in 45-60 minutes of Zone 2 cardio, 4-5 times a week, at an intensity where you can maintain a strained conversation (e.g., high 130s heart rate for a 50-year-old).
    • VO2 Max Training: Perform 3-8 minute high-intensity intervals once a week, pushing yourself to near maximal effort with recovery periods in between (e.g., 4-6 sets of 4-minute intervals).
  11. Prioritise Strength Training: Aim for four strength training sessions per week (two upper body, two lower body). Focus on big, compound lifts, working in the 5-15 rep range with 0-2 reps in reserve to ensure effectiveness without excessive risk.
  12. Integrate Stability Training: Dedicate two full hours a week to stability training, and incorporate at least 20 minutes on other workout days. Consider seeking instruction from a DNS (Dynamic Neuromuscular Stabilisation) practitioner to rebuild optimal movement patterns and prevent injuries.
  13. Reconsider Alcohol Consumption: Be aware that alcohol significantly impairs sleep quality, heart rate variability, and overall recovery. Objective data from sleep trackers clearly shows its detrimental impact.
  14. Proactively Manage Neurodegenerative Risk: Understand your family history for dementia. Implement the "no-regret moves": regular exercise, diligent lipid management, preventing or managing type 2 diabetes, and ensuring adequate, high-quality sleep.
  15. Address the Core Drivers of Heart Disease: Actively work to stop smoking, maintain blood pressure at or below 120/80, and keep APO B levels low (often requiring pharmacologic intervention). Exercise and good sleep also positively impact heart health.
  16. Cultivate Social Connection: Actively foster meaningful relationships and engage with your social group. Recognise that loneliness is detrimental to both emotional and physical health.
  17. Integrate Rejuvenative Practices: Regularly engage in activities like sauna (4-5 times a week at 196-200°F for 30-60 minutes), cold plunging, rucking without electronics, and most importantly, "playing", especially with family, as these contribute significantly to well-being and healthspan.
  18. Prioritise During Stressful Periods: When life demands are high, make deliberate decisions about what to compromise (e.g., temporarily relaxing dietary rules) but strive to protect non-negotiables like sleep and exercise, as these have a greater impact on productivity, cognition, and mood.
  19. Start Today: The "perfect time was yesterday, the next best time is today" to begin implementing these longevity-focused habits.